Shaykh ‘Alā’ al-Dawla Simnānī and His Critique of Ibn ‘Arabī’s Theory of the Unity of Existence

Document Type : The Quarterly Jornal

Author

Lecturer of advanced levels of philosophy and mysticism in the Seminary of Qom, Iran

Abstract

he theory of the unity of existence is one of the most fundamental doctrines of Islamic Sufism and mysticism. According to Muslim mystics, the only true existent is God, and creatures are manifestations and modes of this true existent. The idea was there since the formative period of Islamic mysticism, and found its more accurate accounts after Ibn ‘Arabī’s emergence. Shaykh ‘Alā’ al-Dawla Simnānī—an influential mystic in the 14th century—rejected this theory. In this paper, I deploy an analytic method to consider and criticize Simnānī’s objections to the theory of the unity of existence, after preliminary remarks about his life and work as well as the circumstances of his time. Thus, I argue that Simnānī has criticized Ibn ‘Arabī’s view of the unity of existence and believed in the unity of intuition, instead, because of his belief in the necessity of the separation between Islamic doctrines and Indian religions such as Buddhism for purposes of preventing distortions in Islamic monotheism; because of his failure to grasp the depths of Ibn ‘Arabī’s words about the absolutely unconditioned existence which involves exaltation of God; and because of his confusion of various considerations of existence. Moreover, Simnānī does not believe that the unity of intuition is the ultimate stage of mystical journey, taking the last stage to be that of servitude.

Keywords

References

1. Ibn Arabi. (1370 AP). Fusus al-Hikam (A. A. Afifi, Ed.). Tehran: al-Zahra.
2. Ibn Arabi. (n.d.). The Meccan Illuminations (Vols. 2, 3, 4). Beirut: Dar Sader.
3. Ibn Turkah al-Isfahani, S. (1381 AP). Tamhid al-Qawaid (S. J. Ashtiani, Ed.). Qom: Bustaneketab.
4. Jami, N. A. R. (1370 AP). Nafahat al-Ons min Hazarat al-Quds (M. Abedi, Ed.). Tehran: Ettela’at Institute.
5. Javadi Amoli, A. (1387 AP). A’yn Nadakh (H. Parsania, Ed., Vol. 1). Qom: Esra.
6. Karbalaei Tabrizi, H. H. (1382 AP). Rawdat al-Jannan and Jannat al-Jannan (J. Sultan al-Qara'I & M. A. Sultan al-Qara'i). Tabriz: Sotoudeh.
7. Landolt, H. (1971). Semnanion wahdat al-wujood. Tehran: Collecte Papers on Islamic Philosophy and Mysticism.
8. Mulla Sadra. (1419 AH). The transcendent philosophy in the four journeys (Vol. 1, 2, 7, 5th ed.). Beirut: Dar al-Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi.
9. Nasrollahi, M. (1391 AP). A Study of the Mystical Opinions and Thoughts of Shaykh Ala ‘al-Dawlah Semnani. Qom: Adyan.
10. Qeisari, M. D. (1375 AP). Sharh Fusus al-Hikam (S. J. Ashtiani, Ed.). Tehran: Elmi Farhangi Publishing Co.
11. Qunavi, S. D. (1362 AP). Nusus (S. J. Ashtiani, Ed.). Tehran: University Publishing Center.
12. Rafiei Qazvini, S. A. (1367 AP). Collection of philosophical treatises and articles (Gh. H. Rezanejad, Ed.). Tehran: al-Zahra.
13. Sadr Semnani, S. M. (1334 AP). Description of the life, thoughts and works of Aref Rabbani Abu al-Makarem Rukn al-Din Shaykh Ala 'al-Dawlah Semnani. Tehran: Bin.
14. Semnani, R. D. A. (1362 AP). al-'Urwa li-ahl al-khalwa wa-l-jalwa (N. Mayel Heravi). Tehran: Mola.
15. Semnani, R. D. A. (1364 AP). Complete collection of Persian and Arabic poems (A. R. Haqiqat). Tehran: Moafan and Translators Company.
16. Semnani, R. D. A. (1366 AP). Forty Majlis or Eqbaliyeh Treatise (A. I. Shah bin Sabeq Sajestani & N. Mayel. Heravi, Eds.). Tehran: Adib.
17. Semnani, R. D. A. (1369 AP). Persian manuscripts, treatise of Fath al-Mubin (N. Mayel Heravi). Tehran: Elmi Farhangi Publishing Co.
18. Semnani, R. D. A. (1396 AP). Clarification of positions and determination of degrees (A. Rashedinia, Ed., E. Mortezaei, Trans.). Tehran: Sokhan.
19. Yazdanpanah, S. Y. (1388 AP). Basics and principles of theoretical mysticism (A. Anzali, Ed.). Qom: Imam Khomeini (Ra) Educational and Research Institute.
20. Zarrinkoob, A. H. (1380 AP). Search sequence in Iranian Sufism. Tehran: Amirkabir.
Naqd Va Nazar
Volume 25, Issue 99 - Serial Number 99
September 2020
Pages 127-148

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics