A Critical Consideration of Fanaei’s View of the Reliability of Rational Conjectures

Document Type : The Quarterly Jornal

Author

Meshkat Hawzah, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Abolqasem Fanaei believes in the reliability of rational conjectures (ẓunūn) in fiqh (Islamic jurisprudence), taking it to be irrational to discriminate between transmitted (naqlī) and rational conjectures. In this paper, I aim to criticize and assess four of his arguments for the above claim with an analytic method. Upon these considerations, it will turn out that (1) it is possible for God to put aside the practice of rational beings, (2) from an omniscient perspective, it is possible for speculative conjectures to be characteristically more erroneous than sensory conjectures, (3) unreliability of rational conjectures is specific to the realm of Shari’a and fatwas, not other domains of the life of a believer, (4) prohibition of acting upon rational conjectures does not imply circularity, nor is it self-defeating, and nor does it lead to the shutdown of the reason, and (5) predicaments faced by the traditional jurisprudence do not lead to the reliability of rational conjectures. Based on these points, I have shown that Fanaei’s arguments for irrationality of transmitted and rational conjectures are not plausible. Therefore, there is no justification for ignoring the relevant hadiths.

Keywords

References

  1. The Qur’an
  2. Anṣārī, Shaykh Murtaḍā (1416AH), Farā’id al-Uṣūl, Qom: Mu’assisa al-Nashr al-Islami.
  3. Tabrīzī, Mūsā (1369), Awthaq al-Wasā’il fī Sharḥ al-Rasā’il, Qom: Najafi
  4. Al-Ḥurr al-‘Āmilī, Muḥammad ibn al-Ḥasan (1409AH), Wasā’il al-Shī’a, Qom: Al al-Bayt Institute
  5. Ḥarranī, Ibn Shu’ba (1404AH), Tuḥaf al-‘Uqūl, Qom: Jami’a Mudarrisin.
  6. Sobhani, Mohammad Taghi (1388), “Rationalism and Textualism in Islamic Theology,” in: Alinaghi Khodayari, ed. Origin of Wisdom: Inquiries into Reason, Tehran: Naba’ Publications.
  7. Sadr, Sayyid Muhammad Baqir (1417AH), Buḥūth fī ‘Ilm al-Uṣūl, edited by Hasan ‘Abd al-Satir, Beirut: al-Dar al-Islamiyya.
  8. Sadr, Sayyid Muhammad Baqir (1422AH), Durūs fī‘Ilm al-Uṣūl, Qom: Dar al-Huda.
  9. Al-Ṣadūq, Muḥammad ibn ‘Alī ibn al-Ḥusayn (1376), al-Amālī, Qom: Islamic Publications Office
  10. Al-Ṣadūq, Muḥammad ibn ‘Alī ibn al-Ḥusayn (1403AH), Ma’ānī al-Akhbār, Qom: Islamic Publications Office.
  11. Al-Ṣadūq, Muḥammad ibn ‘Alī ibn al-Ḥusayn (1413AH), Man Lā Yaḥḍuruh al-Faqīh, Qom: Islamic Publications Office.
  12. Alemzadeh Nouri, Mohammad (1396), Inference of Moral Law from Religious Texts and Verbal Evidence, first part, Qom: Islamic Sciences and Culture Academy.
  13. Arab Salehi, Mohammad (1392), “The Nature of Trumping Ruling (ḥukm-i ḥukūmatī) and its Methodological Result,” Huquq-i Islami, no. 37.
  14. Fanaei, Abolqasem (1385), “On the Essence of Religion and the Essence of Modernity,” Ayin, no. 6.
  15. Fanaei, Abolqasem (1391), Critique of Reason-Worshiping and Science-Worshiping, accessed on August 10, 2019 from www.neeloofar.org/115.
  16. Fanaei, Abolqasem (1392a), Religion on the Scale of Ethics, Tehran: Serat Cultural Institute.
  17. Fanaei, Abolqasem (1392b), “Critique of Hadith-Worshiping,” Aseman Weekly, no. 50.
  18. Fanaei, Abolqasem (1393), The Project of Religion and Ethics, accessed on June 6, 2019 from www.neeloofar.org/846.
  19. Fanaei, Abolqasem (1394), Ethics of Religious Studies: A Research on Ethical and Epistemological Foundations of Jurisprudence, Tehran: Negah-e Moaser Publications.
  20. Fanaei, Abolqasem (n/a), On Specification of Prayer Times and Fasting on Long Days, 1-3, accessed on August 14, 2019 from www.neeloofar.org/509.
  21. Kamkar, Hossein (1397), “A Critical Study of Fanaei’s View of the Reliability of Rational Speculations (1),” Naqd va Nazar, no. 92.
  22. Kulaynī, Muḥammad ibn Ya’qūb (1407AH), al-Kāfī, Tehran: Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyya.
  23. Mustafawi, Sayyid Muhammad Kazim (1421AH), Mi’a Qā’ida Fiqhīyya (One Hundred Jurisprudential Rules), Qom: Islamic Publication Office.
  24. Muẓaffar, Muḥammad Riḍā (1375), Uṣūl al-Fiqh, Qom: Esmaeilian.
  25. Malekian, Mostafa and Abolqasem Fanaei (1393), “Living Morally without Governmental Interference,” a conversation in: Andishe-ye Puya, no. 15, pp. 52-63.
  26. Manafi, Sayyed Hossein (1392), “A Consideration of the Reliability of Confidence,” Pazhūhish-hāyi Uṣūlī, no. 19.
  27. Nā’īnī, Muḥammad Ḥusayn (1376), Fawā’id al-Uṣūl, Qom: Jami’a Mudarrisin, Seminary of Qom.

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics