Fallibility, Infallibility or Tolerance: Reflections on Theoretical Foundations of Religious Tolerance

Document Type : Professional

Author

Researcher at Human Rights Studies, Head of Peace and Dialogue Center, University of Religions and Denominations, Qom, Iran

Abstract

The theory of fallibility (takhṭiʾa) in theology and the principles of jurisprudence, if properly understood, can make a significant contribution to prevent violent extremism. Although religious tolerance is considered a modern discourse, this article argues that Muslim theologians had laid down the theoretical foundations of religious tolerance in the eighth century by advancing the theory of fallibility in Islamic theology. Through the fallibility theory, Muslim theologians have concluded that an individual should be excused or rewarded by God even though his/her dogma is false. This would yield an epistemic ground for coexistence among followers of different religions and denominations. Yet, distortions or misapplications of the fallibility theory in the past several decades have led to the emergence of violent extremism across the Muslim world. While revisiting the theory of fallibility in theology and the principles of jurisprudence and by deploying textual analysis in historical contexts, this paper argues that Muslim theologians had laid down the theoretical foundations of religious tolerance on epistemic principles. I conclude that revisiting the theory of fallibility can play a crucial role in preventing violent extremism inside and outside the Muslim world.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

1.    Abi Ya'ala, M. (2009). Al-Idat fi Usul al-Fiqh. (vol. 2) Beirut: Dar al-Kotob al-Ilmiyah.
2.    Abu al-Hussein, M. (1964). Al-Mutamad fi Usul al-Fiqh. Damascus: Al-Ma'ahad al-Ilmi al-Feransi le al-Dirasat al-Arabiyah.
3.    Al-Abdali, Sh. A. (1419 AH). Aqidah al-Muwahedin va al-Rad ala al-Zilal va al-Mubtada'in. Al-Ta'if: Maktabah al-Tarafain. [In Arabic]
4.    Al-Amedi, A. (1402 AH). Al-Ahkam fi Usul al-Ahkam. (vol. 4), Beirut - Damascus: Al-Maktab al-Islami. [In Arabic]
5.    Al-Asqalani, H. (1379 AH). Fath al-Bari be Sharh Sahih al-Bukhari. (Vol. 1). Beirut: Dar Al-Ma'rifah. [In Arabic]
6.    Al-Dawaihi, A. (1421 AH). Ara' al-Mutazilah al-Usuliyah Dirasah va Taqwima. Riyadh: Maktabat al-Rushd. [In Arabic]
7.    Al-Ghazali Al-Tusi, A. (1993). Fesal al-Tafraqah bain al-Islam va Al-Zandaqa. Beirut: Dar al-Fikr.
8.    Al-Ghazali Al-Tusi, A. (2010). Al-Mustasfi min Ilm al-Usul. (Vol. 4). Beirut: Dar Al-Kotob al-Ilmiyah.
9.    Al-Jawini, A. (1987). Ijtihad min Kitab al-Takhlis le Imam al-Haramain. Damascus: Al-Dar Al-Shamiya.
10.    Al-Khorasani (Akhund), Sh. M. K. (1431 AH). Kifayah al-Usul. Qom: Mu'asisah Alulbayt le Ihya al-Torath. [In Arabic]
11.    Al-Murtada, S. SH. (1398 AP). Al-Dari'ah ila al-Usul al-Shari'ah (vol. 2). Mashhad: Astan Quds. [In Persian]
12.    Al-Musawi Al-Zanjani, S. M. (n.d.). Al-Tanqiz le Ahkam al-Taqllid. (vol. 1). 
13.    Al-Qarafi, A. (2004). Sharh Tanqih al-Fusul fi Ikhtisar al-Mahsoul fi al-Usul. Beirut: Dar al-Fikr.
14.    Bashirieh, H. (1370 AP). An Introduction to the History of the Thought of Political Tolerance. Journal of the Faculty of Law and Political Science, 26(2), pp. 119-152. [In Persian]
15.    Bellah, R. N., Sullivan, W. M., Tipton, S., Swidler, A., Madsen, R. (1992). The Good Society. United States: Vintage Books.
16.    Bernard, W. (1996). Toleration: An Impossible Virtue? In: Toleration: An Elusive Virtue (Heyd, D, Ed.), Princeton (Princeton University Press).
17.    Carson, D. (2012). The Intolerance of Tolerance. Cambridge & Michigan (Eerdmans Publishing Company).
18.    Craig, W. L. (2008). Is Uncertainty a Sound Foundation for Religious Toleration? In: Religious Tolerance through Humility: Thinking with Philip Quinn (James Kraft and David Basinger Eds.), USA & UK (Ashgate).
19.    Dadjo, Y. (1394 AP). Disability or entitlement to reward ignorant followers of other religions. Modern Religious Thought, 11(43), pp. 111-128. [In Persian]
20.    Ibn Abi Sharif, K. (1971). Al-Faraid fi Halle Sharh al-Aqa'id. (Hashiyah Ibn Abi Sharif Ala Sharh al-Aqa'id le al-Taftazani). Beirut: Dar al-Kotob al-Ilmiyah.
21.    Ibn Majeh, M. (1996). Sunan Ibn Majeh. (be Sharh al-Imam Abi Al-Hassan Al-Hanafi, known as Sanadi, vol. 3). Beirut: Dar Al-Ma'rifah.
22.    Kendo, M. E. (1404 AH). Manhaj Ibn Hijr al-Asqalani fi al-Aqidh min Khilal Kitab Fath al-Bari. (vol. 1). Riyadh: Maktabah al-Rushd. [In Arabic]
23.    Kilby, K., & Rahner, K. (2004). Theology and Philosophy. London (Routledge).
24.    Mohammad Amin al-Ondonisi, A. (2013). Ijtihad: Tathirah va Tathirah fi Fiqhi al-Maqasid va al-Waqi. Beirut: Dar Al-Kotob al-Ilmiyah.
25.    Montazeri, H. A. (1415 AH). Nahayah al-Usul. (lectures of Haj Hussein Boroujerdi). Qom: Tafakor Publications. [In Arabic]
26.    Newman, J. (1978). The Idea of Religious Tolerance. American Philosophical Quarterly (Vol. 15, No. 3).
27.    Rahner, K. 1986. Karl Rahner in Dialogue: Conversations and Interviews 1965–1982. (Imhof, P., & Biallowons, H, Ed.). New York. (Crossroad).
28.    Ruzgar, M. (2005). Islam and Deep Religious Pluralism. In: Deep Religious Pluralism (Ray Griffin, D, Ed.), Westminster (John Knox Press).
29.    Shokani, M. (2000). Irshad al-Fahoul ila Tahqiq al-Haq min Ilm al-Usul. Beirut: Dar Ibn Kathir.
30.    Tunisia's Constitution of 2014, from: https://www.constituteproject.org/ constitution/Tunisia_2014.pdf
31.    Tusi, M. (1417 AH). Al-Idah fi Usul al-Fiqh. (vols. 1, 2). Qom: Tiz Housh Publications. [In Arabic]
32.    Zidane, G. (1372 AP). History of Islamic Civilization. (Kalam, A. J. Trans. vol. 4). Tehran: Amirkabir Publications. [In Per-sian]

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics