A Reinvestigation of Criteria and Advantages of the Bifurcation of Monotheism into Theoretical and Practical with focus on Imami Theology

Document Type : The Quarterly Jornal

Author

Evaluator

Abstract

In their theological work, some contemporary Imami intellectuals have divided stages of monotheism (tawḥīd) into “theoretical” and “practical.” They have proposed definitions and criteria in order to explain the bifurcation. A consideration of this body of work reveals that there are troubles with these definitions and criteria of the division. A more precise inquiry is needed to resolve these troubles. Moreover, that the bifurcation was not deployed in some other works necessitates a reconsideration of its advantages.
As a conclusion of this library-analytic research, it turns out that (a) theoretical monotheism is in the realm of insights, whereas practical monotheism is to be found in the realms of desire, character, and deeds, (b) in Imami theology or kalām, the division was innovated by Mutahhari—it cannot be found prior to him, (c) although there might be justifications for why the majority of Imami theologians have refrained from making a division between theoretical and practical kinds of monotheism, the bifurcation has its advantages.

Keywords

References

  1. Amid, H. (2010). Farhang-i Farsi (Persian Dictionary) (A. A. Alizadih, Ed.). Tehran: Rah-i Rushd. [In Persian]
  2. Askari, H. (1979). Al-Furuq fi-l-Lugha. Beirut: Dar al-Afaq al-Jadida. [In Arabic]
  3. Abu Hanifa, N. (1980). Al-Fiqh al-Akbar. In Mughnisawi, Abu-l-Muntaha. Al-Rasa’il al-Sab‘a fi-l-‘Aqa’id, Sharh al-Fiqh al-Akbar. Hyderabad: n.p. [In Arabic]
  4. Al-Humsi al-Razi, Sadid al-Din Mahmud. (1981). Al-Munqidh min al-Taqlid (The Rescuer from the Emulation). Vol. 1. Qom: Mu’assisat al-Nashr al-Islami. [In Arabic]
  5. Amuli, S. H. (1973). Al-Muqaddimat min Kitab Nass al-Nusus. Tehran: Iranian Studies Section of Iran-France Institute of Academic Research in Iran. [In Arabic]
  6. Anis, I. (n.d.). Al-Mu‘jam al-Wasit. Tehran: naser khosro. [In Arabic]
  7. Haddad ‘Adil, Gh. A. (1996-2015). Danishnami-yi Jahan-i Islam. Tehran: Encyclopedia Islamica Foundation. [In Arabic]
  8. Ash‘ari, A. (1979). Maqalat al-Islamiyyin wa Ikhtilaf al-Musallin. Wiesbaden, Germany: Franz Steiner. [In Arabic]
  9. Asiri Lahiji, M. (1894). Mafatih al-I‘jaz fi Sharh Gulshan-i Razi (M. M. M. al-Kuttab, Ed.). Mumbai: n.p. [In Arabic]
    1. Astarabadi, M. J. (2003). Al-Barahin al-Qati‘a fi Sharh Tajrid al-‘Aqa’id al-Sati‘a. Qom: Islamic Propagation Office. [In Arabic]
    2. Astarabadi, Radiyy al-Din Muhammad. (1981). Sharh Shafiya Ibn Hajib (M. Nur al-Hasan, M. al-Zafzaf, & M. Muhyi-l-Din ‘Abd al-Hamid, Eds., Vol. 1). Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya. [In Arabic]
    3. Azhari, M. (2000). Tahdhib al-Lugha (Vol. 5). Beirut: Dar Ihya’ al-Turath al-‘Arabi. [In Arabic]
    4. Dihkhuda, A. A. (1958-1967). Lughatnamih (M. Mu‘in, Ed., Vol. 15). Tehran: University of Tehran. [In Persian]
    5. Farahidi, Kh. (1988). Kitab al-‘Ayn (Vol. 3). Qom: Hijrat Publications. [In Arabic]
    6. Fayd Kashani, Muhammad ibn Murtada. (2002). Al-Haqa’iq fi Mahasin al-Akhlaq (The Truths in Good Morals). Edited by Muhsin ‘Aqil. Qom: Dar al-Kitab al-Islami. [In Arabic]
    7. Fayyad Lahiji, ‘Abd al-Razzaq. (n.d.). Shawariq al-Ilham fi Sharh Tajrid al-Kalam (Illuminations of Inspiration in Elaboration of Abstraction of Theology). Vol. 1. Isfahan: Mahdawi. [In Arabic]
    8. Firuzabadi, Muhammad ibn Ya‘qub. (1994). Al-Qamus al-Muhit (The Comprehensive Dictionary). Volumes 1 and 2. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya. [In Arabic]
    9. Halabi, Taqiyy al-Din Abu-l-Salah. (1983). Taqrib al-Ma‘arif (Approximation of the Doctrines). Edited by Riza Ustadi. Qom: al-Hadi. [In Arabic]
    10. Hanafi, Ibn Abi-l-‘Aziz. (2005). Sharh al-‘Aqidat al-Tahawiyya (Elaboration of the Tahawi Belief). Edited by Nasir al-Din Albani. Baghdad: Dar al-Kitab al-‘Arabi. [In Arabic]
    11. Haras, Muhammad Khalil. (1994). Sharh al-Qasidat al-Nuniyya (Elaboration of Nuni Qasida). Vol. 2. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya. [In Arabic]
    12. Hilli, al-Hasan ibn Yusuf. (1982). Kashf al-Murad fi Sharh Tajrid al-I‘tiad (The Discovery of the Meaning in Elaboration of Abstraction of the Belief). Edited and commented by Hasan Hasanzadih Amuli. Qom: Mu’assisat al-Nashr al-Islami. [In Arabic]
    13. Hilli, al-Hasan ibn Yusuf. (1982). Nahj al-Haqq wa Kashf al-Sidq (The Way of the Truth and the Discovery of the Reality). Commented by ‘Ayn Allah Hasani Armawi. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-Lubnani. [In Arabic]
    14. Hilli, Ja‘far ibn al-Hasan. (1983). Al-Maslak fi Usul al-Din (The Manner in the Principles of the Religion). Edited by Riza Ustadi. Mashhad: Majma‘ al-Buhuth al-Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
    15. Hilli, Ja‘far ibn al-Hasan. (1997). Risala fi-l-‘Aqida (An Essay on the Belief). In Chahar Risali-yi I‘tiqadi (Four Doctrinal Essays) in Miras-i Islami-yi Iran (Iran’s Islamic Heritage). Vol. 6. Edited by Rasul Ja‘fariyan. Qom: Library of Ayatollah Mar‘ashi Najafi. [In Arabic]
    16. Husayni Lawasani, Sayyid Hasan. (2004). Nur al-Afham fi ‘Ilm al-Kalam (The Lights of Understanding in the Science of Kalam). Vol. 1. Edited by Sayyid Ibrahim Lawasani. Qom: Islamic Publication Institute. [In Arabic]
    17. Husayni Zubaydi, Muhammad Murtada. (1993). Taj al-‘Arus min Jawahir al-Qamus (The Crown of the Bride from Jewelry of the Dictionary). Vol. 5. Edited by ‘Ali Hilali and ‘Ali Sayri. Beirut: Dar al-Fikr. [In Arabic]
    18. Ibn ‘Ibad, Isma‘il. (1983). Al-Muhit fi-l-Lugha (The Surround in Vocabulary). Vol. 3. Edited by Muhammad Hasan Al Yasin. Beirut: ‘Alam al-Kitab. [In Arabic]
    19. Ibn al-Faris, Ahmad. (1983). Mu‘jam Maqayis al-Lugha (Dictionary of the Scales of Vocabulary). Volumes 5 and 6. Edited by ‘Abd al-Salam Muhammad Harun. Qom: Islamic Propagation Office. [In Arabic]
    20. Ibn al-Manzur, Muhammad ibn Mukram. (1993). Lisan al-‘Arab (The Language of Arabs). Vol. 5. Beirut: Dar Sadir. [In Arabic]
    21. Ibn Manda, Muhammad ibn Ishaq. (2002). Al-Tawhid wa Ma‘rifa Asma’ Allah ‘Azz wa Jall wa Sifatuh (Monotheism and Knowledge of the Exalted Honored God’s Names and Attributes). Edited by ‘Ali Muhammad Nasir Faqihi. Medina: Maktabat al-‘Ulum wa-l-Hikam. [In Arabic]
    22. Ibn Nubakht, Abu Ishaq Ibrahim. (1992). Al-Yaqut fi ‘Ilm al-Kalam (The Ruby in the Science of Kalam). Edited by ‘Ali Akbar Ziya’i. Qom: Library of Ayatollah Mar‘ashi Najafi. [In Arabic]
    23. Ibn Qayyim, Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr. (2004). Madarij al-Salikin (Degrees of Spiritual Travelers). Edited by ‘Abd al-Ghaniyy al-Fasi. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya. [In Arabic]
    24. Ibn Sayyida, ‘Ali ibn Isma‘il. (2000). Al-Muhkam wa-l-Muhit al-A‘zam (The Firm and the Greatest Surround). Vol. 3. Edited by ‘Abd al-Hamid Hindawi. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya. [In Arabic]
    25. Ibn Taymiyya, Ahmad ibn ‘Abd al-Halim. (1999). Al-Tis‘iniyya (The Ennead). Vol. 3. Riyadh: Maktabat al-Ma‘arif. [In Arabic]
    26. Ibn Taymiyya, Ahmad ibn ‘Abd al-Halim. (2000). Mahmu‘ al-Fatawa (Collected Fatwas). Vol. 1. Beirut: Mustafa ‘Abd al-Qadir ‘Ata’.
    27. Javadi Amuli, ‘Abd Allah. (2014). Tafsir-i Mawzu‘i-yi Qur’an-i Karim: Towhid dar Qur’an (The Topical Exegesis of the Dignified Qur’an: Monotheism in the Qur’an). Vol. 2. Edited by Haydar ‘Ali Ayyubi. Qom: Isra’. [In Persian]
    28. Jurjani, Mir Sayyid Sharif. (1907). Sharh al-Maqaqif (Elaboration of the Positions). Vol. 1. Edited by Badr al-Na‘sani. Qom: al-Sharif al-Raziyy. [In Arabic]
    29. Jurjani, Mir Sayyid Sharif. (1991). Al-Ta‘rifat (The Definitions). Tehran: Nasir Khusrow. [In Arabic]
    30. Kabir Madani, Sayyid ‘Ali Khan ibn Ahmad. (2005). Al-Taraz al-Awwal wa-l-Kunaz li-ma ‘alayh min Lughat al-‘Arab al-Ma‘mul (The Primary Style and Treasures for the Common Arabic Vocabulary). Vol. 6. Edited by Mu’assisa Al al-Bayt li-Ihya’ al-Turath. Mashhad: Mu’assisa Al al-Bayt li-Ihya’ al-Turath. [In Arabic]
    31. Kashani, ‘Izz al-Din Mahmud. (n.d.). Misbah al-Hidaya wa Miftah al-Kifaya (The Light of the Guidance and the Key of the Sufficiency). Tehran: Huma Publications. [In Arabic]
    32. Kashif al-Ghita’, Ja‘far ibn Khidr. (2004). Al-‘Aqa’id al-Ja‘fariyya (The Ja‘fari Beliefs). Edited by Sayyid Mahdi Shams al-Din. Qom: Ansariyan Institute. [In Arabic]
    33. Khandan, ‘Ali Asghar. (2010). Towhid va Shirk dar Ma‘rifat va ‘Ulum-i Insani ba Ta’kid bar Athar va Andishi-hayi Ustad Shahid Murtaza Mutahhari. (Monotheism and Polytheism in Knowledge and Human Sciences with Focus on Mutaza Mutahhari’s Work and Thoughts). Ma‘rifat-i Kalami 1, no. 4: pp .143-178. [In Persian]
    34. Kharrazi, Sayyid Muhsin. (1996). Bidayat al-Ma‘arif al-Ilahiyya fi Sharh ‘Aqa’id al-Imamiyya (The Beginning of the Divine Doctrines in Elaboration of Imami Beliefs). Vol. 1. Qom: Mu’assisat al-Nashr al-Islami. [In Arabic]
    35. Khudaparasti, Faraj Allah. (1997). Farhang-i Jami‘-i Vazhgan-i Mutaradif va Mutazadd-i Zaban-i Farsi (The Comprehensive Dictionary of Persian Synonyms and Antonyms). Shiraz: Danishnami-yi Fars. [In Persian]
    36. Khurasani, Muhammad Jawad. (1995). Hidayat al-Umma ila Ma‘arif al-A’imma (Guidance of the Nation to the Doctrines of the Imams). Qom: Mu’assisat al-Bi‘tha. [In Arabic]
    37. Makarim Shirazi, Nasir. (2006). Durus fi-l-‘Aqa’id al-Islamiyya (Lessons in Islamic Beliefs). Qom: The School of Imam ‘Ali ibn Abi Talib. [In Arabic]
    38. Maturidi, Muhammad ibn Muhammad. (2006). Al-Tawhid (Monotheism). Edited by Fath Allah Khalif. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya. [In Arabic]
    39. Misbah Yazdi, Muhammad Taqi. (1999). Amuzish-i ‘Aqa’id (Teaching the Beliefs). Vol. 1. Tehran: International Printing and Publishing of Islamic Development Organization. [In Persian]
    40. Mu‘in, Muhammad. (2007). Farhang-i Farsi (Persian Dictionary). Vol. 4. Edited by ‘Aziz Allah ‘Alizadih and Mahmud Namani. Tehran: Naman. [In Persian]
    41. Mufid, Muhammad ibn Muhammad. (1992 a). Al-Nukat al-I‘tiqadiyya (Doctrinal Points). Qom: World Conference of Shaykh Mufid. [In Arabic]
    42. Mufid, Muhammad ibn Muhammad. (1992 b). Awa’il al-Maqalat fi-l-Madhahib wa-l-Mukhtarat (Early Articles in Denominations and the Selected). Qom: World Conference of Shaykh Mufid. [In Arabic]
    43. Mufti, Hamid. (1995). Qamus al-Bahrayn. Edited by ‘Ali Awjabi. Tehran: Miras-i Maktub. [In Arabic]
    44. Mustafawi, Hasan. (2009). Al-Tahqiq fi Kalimat al-Qur’an al-Karim (Investigation of the Words of the Dignified Qur’an). Vol. 12. Beirut, Cairo, and London: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya and Center for Publication of ‘Allama Mustafawi’s Work. [In Arabic]
    45. Mutahhari, Murtaza. (1999). ‘Aqa’id al-Imamiyya (Imami Beliefs). Edited by Hamid Hanafi. Qom: Ansariyan. [In Arabic]
    46. Mutahhari, Murtaza. (2010 a). Collected Work. Vol. 2. Qom: Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences, Mutahhari’s Collected Work Software. [In Persian]
    47. Mutahhari, Murtaza. (2010 b). Collected Work. Vol. 3. Qom: Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences, Mutahhari’s Collected Work Software. [In Persian]
    48. Mutahhari, Murtaza. (2010 c). Collected Work. Vol. 16. Qom: Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences, Mutahhari’s Collected Work Software. [In Persian]
    49. Mutahhari, Murtaza. (2010 d). Collected Work. Vol. 26. Qom: Computer Research Center of Islamic Sciences, Mutahhari’s Collected Work Software. [In Persian]
    50. Muzaffar, Muhammad Riza. (1997). Al-Mantiq (The Logic). Qom: Sayyid al-Shuhada’. [In Arabic]
    51. Naraqi, Ahmad ibn Muhammad Mahdi. (1999). Mi‘raj al-Sa‘ada (The Ascent of Happiness). Qom: Hijrat. [In Persian]
    52. Naraqi, Mahdi ibn Abi Dharr. (1990). Anis al-Muwahhidin (The Companion of the Monotheists). Edited and commented by Sayyid Muhammad ‘Ali Qadi Tabataba’i. Tehran: al-Zahra’. [In Arabic]
    53. Nasafi, ‘Aziz al-Din ibn Muhammad. (2007). Al-Insan al-Kamil (The Perfect Human). Edited by Marijan Mole. Tehran: Tahuri. [In Arabic]
    54. Nishaburi, Nizam al-Din Hasan ibn Muhammad. (2013). Sharh al-Nizam ‘ala al-Shafiya. Edited by Muhammad Zaki Ja‘fari. Qom: Dar al-Hujja. [In Arabic]
    55. Qadi ‘Abd al-Jabbar, Abu-l-Hasan ibn Ahmad. (1986). Al-Majmu‘ fi-l-Muhit bi-l-Taklif (The Compendium in Surrounding the Obligation). Vol. 1. Beirut: Dar al-Mashriq. [In Arabic]
    56. Qadi ‘Abd al-Jabbar, Abu-l-Hasan ibn Ahmad. (2001). Sharh al-Usul al-Khamsa (Elaboration of the Five Principles). Commented by Ahmad ibn Husayn ibn Abi Hsahim. Beirut: Dar Ihya’ al-Turath al-‘Arabi. [In Arabic]
    57. Qari, Mulla ‘Ali. (2007). Sharh Kitab al-Fiqh al-Akbar (Elaboration of the Book, the Greatest Jurisprudence). Commented by ‘Ali Muhammad Dandal. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya. [In Arabic]
    58. Rabbani Gulpayigani, ‘Ali. (2005). ‘Aqa’id-i Istidlali (Argumentative Beliefs). Vol. 1. Qom: Sanabil. [In Persian]
    59. Rabbani, Gulpayigani, ‘Ali. (2008). Kalam-i Tatbiqi (Comparative Theology). Vol. 1. Qom: Al-Mustafa International University. [In Persian]
    60. Raghib Isfahani, Husayn ibn Muhammad. (1991). Mufradat Alfaz al-Qur’an (The Single Words of the Qur’an). Beirut: Dar al-Qalam. [In Arabic]
    61. Sa‘idi Mihr, Muhammad. (2013). Amuzish-i Kalam-i Islami (Teaching Islamic Theology). Vol. 1. Qom: Taha. New edition. [In Persian]
    62. Saduq, Muhammad ibn ‘Ali. (1977). Al-Tawhid (Monotheism). Edited by Hashim Husayni. Qom: Jami‘i-yi Mudarrisin. [In Arabic]
    63. Saduq, Muhammad ibn ‘Ali. (1993). Al-I‘tiqadat (The Beliefs). Qom: World Conference for Shaykh Mufid. [In Arabic]
    64. Shahid Thani, Zayn al-Din ibn ‘Ali. (1992). Al-Tanbihat al-‘Aliyya ‘ala Waza’if al-Salat al-Qalbiyya (High Reminders for Obligations of Prayer in the Heart). Edited by Safa’ al-Din Basri. Mashhad: Astan-i Quds-i Razavi. [In Arabic]
    65. Shakirin, Hamid Riza. (2015). Ravish-Shinasi-yi ‘Aqa’id-i Dini (The Methodology of Religious Beliefs). Tehran: Islamic Research Institute for Culture and Thought. [In Persian]
    66. Sharif Murtada, ‘Ali ibn al-Husayn. (1967). Jumal al-‘Ilm wa-l-‘Amal (Statements of Knowledge and Action). Najaf: Matba‘at al-Adab. [In Arabic]
    67. Shubbar, Sayyid ‘Abd Allah. (2003). Haqq al-Yaqin fi Ma‘rifa Usul al-Din (The Truth of Certitude in Knowledge of the Principles of the Religion). Qom: Anwar al-Huda. [In Arabic]
    68. Shubbar, Sayyid ‘Abd Allah. (n.d.). Al-Akhlaq (Ethics). Edited by Jawad Shubbar. Najaf: Matba‘at al-Nu‘man. [In Arabic]
    69. Sikandari, Ahmad ibn ‘Ata’ Allah and ‘Abd al-Hamid ibn Badis. (2005). Taj al-‘Arus al-Hawi li-Tahdhib al-Nufus (The Bride’s Crown Containing the Refinement of the Souls). Edited by Ahmad Farid al-Mazidi. Beirut: Dar al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya. [In Arabic]
    70. Subhani, Ja‘far. (1991). Al-Ilahiyyat ‘ala Huda al-Kitab wa-l-Sunna wa-l-‘Aql (The Theology with the Guidance of the Book and the Tradition and Reason). Vol. 2. Qom: Al-Mu’tamar al-‘Alami li-l-Dirasat al-Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
    71. Subhani, Ja‘far. (2004). Rasa’il va Maqalat (Essays and Articles). Vol. 5. Qom: Mu’assisat al-Imam al-Sadiq. [In Persian]
    72. Suyuri Hilli, Miqdad ibn ‘Abd Allah and Abul-Fath ibn Makhdum Husayni. (1986). Al-Bab al-Hadi ‘Ashr ma‘a Shahiyya al-Nafi‘ Yawm al-Hashr wa Miftah al-Bab (The Eleventh Gate with the Elaboration of the Useful on the Day of Resurrection and the Gate’s Key). Edited by Mahdi Muhaqqiq. Tehran: Institute for Islamic Studies. [In Arabic]
    73. Suyuri Hilli, Miqdad ibn ‘Abd Allah. (1984). Irshad al-Talibin ila Nahj al-Mustarshidin (The Guidance of the Aspirants to the Way of the Guided). Edited by Sayyid Mahdi Raja’i. Qom: Library of Ayatollah Mar‘ashi Najafi. [In Arabic]
    74. Suyuri Hilli, Miqdad ibn ‘Abd Allah. (1991). Al-I‘timad fi Sharh Wajib al-I‘tiqad. Edited by Ziya’ al-Din Basri. Mashhad: Majma‘ al-Buhuth al-Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
    75. Suyuri Hilli, Miqdad ibn ‘Abd Allah. (1999). Al-Anwar al-Jalaliyya fi Sharh al-Fusul al-Nasiriyya (The Glorious Lights in Elaboration of Nasiri Chapters). Edited by ‘Ali Haji Abadi and ‘Abbas Jalaliniya. Mashhad: Majma‘ al-Buhuth al-Islamiyya. [In Arabic]
    76. Tabarsi, Fadl ibn al-Hasan. (1993). Majma‘ al-Bayan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an (F. Yazdi & H. Rasuli, Eds., Vol. 1). Tehran: Nasir Khusrow. [In Arabic]
    77. Tabataba’i, Sayyid Muhammad Husayn. (1970). Al-Mizan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an (Vol. 1). Beirut: al-A‘lami Institute. [In Arabic]
    78. Taftazani, S. (1988). Sharh al-Maqasid (Elaboration of the Destinations). Vol. 1. Edited by ‘Abd al-Rahman ‘Umayra. Qom: al-Sharif al-Radiyy. [In Arabic]
    79. Tahanawi, M. A. (1996). Mawsu‘a Kashshaf Istilahat al-Funun wa-l-‘Ulum (A. Dahruj, Ed., Vols. 1, 2). Beirut: Maktaba Lubnan al-Nashirun. [In Arabic]
    80. Tusi, M. (1993). Masa’il Kalamiyya. In al-Rasa’il al-‘Ashr (The Ten Essays). Qom: Mu’assisat al-Nashr al-Islami. [In Arabic]
    81. Tusi, M. (n.d.). Al-Tibyan fi Tafsir al-Qur’an (H. Amili, Ed., Vol. 2). Beirut: Dar Ihya’ al-Turath al-‘Arabi. [In Arabic]

 

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics