A Critical Assessment of Civil Disobedience in the View of Ancient Greek and Enlightenment Philosophers

Document Type : The Quarterly Jornal

Authors

1 Assistant professor in Islamic Sciences and Culture Academy

2 Researcher

Abstract

Even if we take Sophocles’s writing about civil disobedience to be philosophically irrelevant, we cannot close our eyes to Socrates and his philosophical view of such disobedience. When he was wrongly sentenced to death by the Athenian government, he refused to listen to his friends, disobey the issued ruling, and escape from the prison, because he considered civil disobedience as contrary to virtues and social conventions. The view was, however, adamantly opposed by people who believed that laws are sometimes so unjust that it is necessary to resist them with civil disobedience as the last possible way. Given the two views about civil disobedience, the fundamental question is which act is admirable towards unjust laws: should we keep obeying unjust laws in any possible ways, or can we object to them and force the government to acquiesce to reforms? In this paper, we seek to answer this question by criticizing and considering arguments from Ancient Greece and the Enlightenment period, and then uncover their internal contradictions.

Keywords

References

  1. Ahmadi, Omid (1394), “Respect for Law in Plato’s Thought,” Muta’liāt-i Ḥuqūq-i ‘Umūmī, vol. 45, no. 1.
  2. Aristotle (1385), Nicomachean Ethics, translated into Persian by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Tehran: Trah-e Now.
  3. Plato (1353), Republic, translated into Persian by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Tehran: Khoosheh.
  4. Plato (1354), The Laws, translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Tehran: Safi-Ali Shah Press Institute.
  5. Plato (1357), Collection of Works, translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi and Reza Kaviani, vol. 1, Tehran: Kharazmi.
  6. Palmer, Michael (1388), Moral Problems, translated into Persian by Alireza Alebouyeh, Qom: Islamic Sciences and Culture Academy.
  7. Javadi, Mohammad Aslam (1394), “What is a Social Movement?” Jame’e-ye Baz Newspaper, year 4, no. 735, news code: 39005, 7.
  8. Russell, Bertrand (1340), History of Western Philosophy, translated by Najaf Daryabandari, vol. 1 and 3, first edition, Tehran: Organization for Pocket Books.
  9. Rawls, John (1387), A Theory of Justice, translated into Persian by Sayyed Mohammad Kamal Sarvarian and Morteza Bahrani, Tehran: Research Center for Social and Cultural Studies.
  10. Rousseau, Jean Jacques (1341), Social Convention, translated into Persian by Gholamhossein Zirak, fourth edition, Tehran: Chehreh Publication Company.
  11. Sophocles (1352), Theban Plays, translated into Persian by Shahrokh Meskoub, Tehran: Kharazmi.
  12. Kurlansky, Mark (1390), Nonviolence, translated into Persian by Abdorreza Mahdavi, Tehran: Peykan Publications.
  13. Locke, John (1387), The Second Treatise of Government, translated into Persian by Shahram Arshadnejad, edited by Mostafa Dehghan, Tehran: Roshangaran va Motale’at-e Zanan.
  14. Kraut, Richard (1984), Socrates and the State, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
  15. King, Martin Luther, Jr. (1963), “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” Liberation: An Independent Monthly, Vol. 8, no. 4.
  16. Rozmarynowska, Karolina (2016), “civil disobedience and ethical meaning,” Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński University in Warsaw, tom lxiv, numer 2.
  17. Rex, Martin (2015), “Civil Disobedience,” International Journal of Ethics, Vol. 48, No. 3, University of Chicago, Publications section.
  18. Thoreau, Henry David (1849), “Resistance to Civil Government,” in:https://sniggle.net/TPL/index5.php?entry=rtcg#p1-46.
Naqd Va Nazar
Volume 24, Issue 96 - Serial Number 96
February 2020
Pages 76-102

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics